J. Pedro Ribeiro

Book Review: Smashing Book 2

January 18, 2012

buch dummy big 3

A couple months ago I finished reading The Smashing Book 2 from the popular web design blog Smashing Magazine. Just like with the first book, I got disappointed. It looks good, it feels good (awesome printing), it covers a variety of topics, but to me it just doesn’t work.

For starter, it feels like a bunch of blog articles put together. I can’t feel the connection among them. Like I said, it covers a wide range of topics, from e-commerce to mobile, typography and print design. I found myself skipping several pages until finding something that I’m actually interested in. Too many different areas covered also means I won’t use the book as a quick reference. Maybe this was intentional so they could reach a broader audience, just a guess.

One chapter in particular covers design patterns in e-commerce based on a research with over 50 websites. Even though the content and results are well put together, this is hardly something I want to read in a book. It would make more sense to see it in a magazine as the results will become dated very fast.

The Smashing Book 2 is not a bad book. It is well written and the authors go very deep into each chapter, they are very informative although not so useful in practise. The chapters cover a lot about strategy and theory.

It’s a great improvement from their first try and I’m sure a lot of people will like it. It just isn’t the book I was expecting considering what Smashing Magazine represents to the web community.

J. Pedro Ribeiro

I’m a Brazilian front-end developer living in London. This website features some of my latest projects and my thoughts on anything web related.
You can find me on Twitter, Instagram, and LinkedIn.
Wanna talk? Send me a message.